A traditional pie lives or dies on three things: a hot oven, a thin layer of sauce, and dry toppings. Every step below is built around those.
Flip a heavy sheet pan upside down and preheat it the same way. Or bake each pizza in a 12 inch cast iron skillet for a thicker, crispier pan pizza.
Start the dough first. It needs about an hour to double, and everything else gets done while it rises. Using store dough? Pull it out of the fridge now so it can come to room temperature, then skip to step two.
Pizzerias bake around 700°F. A home oven tops out lower, so the stone has to soak up heat for a long time to make up the difference. This is the most important step on the page.
Build each pizza on a sheet of parchment on the back of a sheet pan, and slide the parchment and all onto the stone. Pull the paper out after 4 minutes, once the bottom has set.
The sauce doesn't get cooked on the stove. It cooks on the pizza, and that's what keeps it bright. The mushrooms are the opposite: they get cooked first, because raw mushrooms dump water and make the middle soggy.
Less is more. Too much sauce or cheese and the middle never gets crisp. The pepperoni goes on last so it cups up and crisps at the edges.
Work fast when the oven door is open. Every second it's open, the oven loses heat.
Guaraldi while the dough rises, Dean Martin for the Italian-American part, and Brenda Lee and Darlene Love when the pizzas start coming out.
Sangiovese from Tuscany, the classic pizza wine. Bright cherry and enough acid to match tomato sauce and cut the cheese. Italy section, look for the black rooster on the neck.
The holiday IPA that comes out every fall. Piney and citrusy with fresh hops. Great with pepperoni.
Italian and Christmas red. Bitter and bright before dinner.
About 300 calories a slice. The crust is most of the carbs, and the cheese, pepperoni, and garlic butter are most of the fat. Drinks not counted.