Christmas at home

Pepperoni Mushroom PizzaGarlic Butter Crust

A from-scratch dough, a raw San Marzano sauce, cupped pepperoni, browned mushrooms, sliced garlic, and herbs. Two 12 inch pies out of a screaming hot oven.
Two 12″ pizzas~2 hrs with dough, 1 hr withoutOven at 550°F
What Goes On

The ingredients.

A traditional pie lives or dies on three things: a hot oven, a thin layer of sauce, and dry toppings. Every step below is built around those.

The Dough

375 g / 3 cupsbread flour
280 g / 1¼ cupswarm water, 110°F
2¼ tspinstant yeast (1 packet)
1½ tspkosher salt
1 tspsugar
2 tbspolive oil
or 2 lbstore dough, two balls

The Sauce

28 oz canSan Marzano tomatoes
1 tbspolive oil
2 clovesgarlic, grated
1 tspdried oregano
½ tspkosher salt
pinchsugar, red pepper flakes
4 leavesfresh basil, torn

On Top

1 lblow-moisture mozzarella, shredded
½ cupParmigiano, grated
6 ozcupping pepperoni
8 ozcremini mushrooms, sliced
4 clovesgarlic, thinly sliced
3 tbsp + 2 clovesbutter and garlic, for the crust
 basil, parsley, chili flakes, hot honey
No Stone?

Flip a heavy sheet pan upside down and preheat it the same way. Or bake each pizza in a 12 inch cast iron skillet for a thicker, crispier pan pizza.

The Evening

How it goes.

0:00Mix and knead the dough. It rises while you do everything else.
0:15Stone into the oven, oven to 550°F.
0:20Sauce, mushrooms, garlic butter, shred the cheese.
1:15Dough has doubled. Divide into two balls, rest 15.
1:30Stretch and build pizza one.
1:35Pizza one in for about 9 minutes.
1:50Pizza two in while you slice the first.
2:00Both on the table.
Step One · The Dough

Mix, knead, and let it rise.

Start the dough first. It needs about an hour to double, and everything else gets done while it rises. Using store dough? Pull it out of the fridge now so it can come to room temperature, then skip to step two.

A · Wake the Yeast
In a big bowl, stir 1 tsp sugar and 2¼ tsp instant yeast into 280 g warm water. It should feel like a warm bath, about 110°F. Too hot kills the yeast. Let it sit until a little foamy.
B · Mix
Add 375 g bread flour, 1½ tsp salt, and 2 tbsp olive oil. Stir with a spoon until there's no dry flour left. It'll be shaggy and sticky.
C · Knead
Turn it out on a lightly floured counter. Push it away with the heel of your hand, fold it back, turn it a quarter turn, and repeat. Keep going until it's smooth and springs back slowly when you poke it.
D · Rise
Into a bowl rubbed with olive oil, turn once to coat, and cover with plastic or a damp towel. Somewhere warm, like on top of the stove while the oven preheats. It's ready when it's doubled in size.
♪ Press playChristmas Time Is Here · Vince Guaraldi Trio
110°FWater
2×Rise to double
The Dough
Bloom
Knead
Rise
Smooth, springythen let it work
Step Two · The Oven

As hot as it goes, for a long time.

Pizzerias bake around 700°F. A home oven tops out lower, so the stone has to soak up heat for a long time to make up the difference. This is the most important step on the page.

A · Stone In
Put your pizza stone, steel, or upside-down sheet pan on a rack in the upper third of the oven. The top of the oven is hotter and browns the cheese faster.
B · Crank It
Set the oven to 550°F, or as high as it goes. Give the stone a full 45 minutes, even after the oven says it's preheated. The air gets hot fast, but the stone takes much longer.
No Peel?

Build each pizza on a sheet of parchment on the back of a sheet pan, and slide the parchment and all onto the stone. Pull the paper out after 4 minutes, once the bottom has set.

550°FOven
45 minStone soak
The Oven
Stone heats
Upper thirdhottest spot
Step Three · Sauce and Toppings

Raw sauce, dry mushrooms.

The sauce doesn't get cooked on the stove. It cooks on the pizza, and that's what keeps it bright. The mushrooms are the opposite: they get cooked first, because raw mushrooms dump water and make the middle soggy.

A · Sauce
Pour the tomatoes into a bowl and crush them with your hands until there are no big chunks. Stir in 1 tbsp olive oil, 2 grated garlic cloves, 1 tsp oregano, ½ tsp salt, a pinch each of sugar and red pepper flakes, and the torn basil. That's it. You'll have extra.
B · Mushrooms
Slice the creminis ¼ inch thick. Cast iron over medium-high with a little olive oil. Spread them out, don't stir for 3 minutes, then toss with a pinch of salt and cook until browned and all their water is gone.
C · Garlic Butter
Melt 3 tbsp butter with 2 grated garlic cloves, a pinch of salt, and a tablespoon of chopped parsley. This goes on the crust.
D · Everything Else
Shred the mozzarella and grate the Parmigiano. Thinly slice 4 garlic cloves. Split everything into two piles so each pizza gets half.
♪ Cook toLet It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow! · Dean Martin
RawSauce
DryMushrooms
Prep
Mushrooms
Saucehand-crushed, no stove
Garlic buttermelted, parsley in
Two pilesone per pizza
Step Four · Stretch and Build

Stretch by hand, then go light.

Less is more. Too much sauce or cheese and the middle never gets crisp. The pepperoni goes on last so it cups up and crisps at the edges.

A · Divide and Rest
Punch the risen dough down, cut it in half, and roll each into a tight ball. Cover and let them rest so the gluten relaxes. Skip this and the dough fights you and shrinks back.
B · Stretch
On a floured counter, press the ball flat with your fingertips from the center out, leaving a 1 inch rim untouched. Then pick it up and let it hang over your knuckles, rotating, until it's about 12 inches. No rolling pin, since that squeezes out the air that makes the crust puffy.
C · Build
On a peel dusted with cornmeal, or on parchment:
  • About ½ cup of sauce, spread thin, leaving the rim bare
  • A light dusting of Parmigiano
  • Half the mozzarella
  • Half the mushrooms and sliced garlic
  • Pepperoni on top
  • A pinch of dried oregano
D · Butter the Crust
Brush the bare rim with the garlic butter. Give the peel a shake to make sure the pizza slides before you head to the oven.
♪ Cook toThe Christmas Song · Nat King Cole
12″Per pizza
½ cupSauce
Build
Rest
Ordersauce, Parm, mozz, mushroom, garlic, pepperoni
Shake testit should slide
Step Five · The Bake

Nine minutes, then do it again.

Work fast when the oven door is open. Every second it's open, the oven loses heat.

A · Launch
Open the oven, set the tip of the peel at the back of the stone, and pull the peel out in one quick jerk so the pizza slides off. With parchment, slide the whole sheet on.
B · Bake
Done when the crust is deep golden with some dark spots, the cheese is bubbling and browned in places, and the pepperoni have cupped. If the top needs more color, switch to broil for the last 60 seconds and watch it.
C · Finish
Out onto a board. Brush the crust again with garlic butter, then fresh basil, grated Parmigiano, red pepper flakes, and a drizzle of hot honey if you have it. Rest 2 minutes before slicing so the cheese sets.
D · Pizza Two
Let the stone heat back up for 5 minutes while you build the second pizza, then bake it the same way.
♪ Cook toRockin' Around the Christmas Tree · Brenda Lee
● PourChianti Classico · pour it now, pizza two is in
9 minPer pizza
BroilLast 60 sec
The Bake
Pizza one
Rest
Stone recovers
Pizza two
16 slices8 per pie
Two Plates

Same pies, two ways.

Pizza Night

Three Slices
  • Three slices, crusts and all
  • Hot honey and chili flakes
  • Garlic butter on the crust
  • Chianti

Lighter Plate

Two Slices and a Salad
  • Two slices
  • An arugula salad with lemon and olive oil
  • Skip the extra garlic butter
  • Sparkling water with lime
The Soundtrack · Christmas Classics

Pizza and Christmas records.

1Christmas Time Is HereVince Guaraldi Trio
2Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!Dean Martin
3The Christmas SongNat King Cole
4Rockin' Around the Christmas TreeBrenda Lee
5Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)Darlene Love
6Linus and LucyVince Guaraldi Trio

Guaraldi while the dough rises, Dean Martin for the Italian-American part, and Brenda Lee and Darlene Love when the pizzas start coming out.

The Pour

What to drink.

The Pick

Chianti Classico

Sangiovese from Tuscany, the classic pizza wine. Bright cherry and enough acid to match tomato sauce and cut the cheese. Italy section, look for the black rooster on the neck.

The Christmas Beer

Sierra Nevada Celebration

The holiday IPA that comes out every fall. Piney and citrusy with fresh hops. Great with pepperoni.

Red and Green

Negroni

Italian and Christmas red. Bitter and bright before dinner.

1 ozgin
1 ozCampari
1 ozsweet vermouth
Stirover ice, big cube in a rocks glass
Garnishorange peel, plus a rosemary sprig
For the Tracker

Macros.

Pizza Night

3 slices of 16, with garlic butter
Cal
~930
Protein
42g
Carbs
93g
Fat
42g

Lighter Plate

2 slices, no extra butter, side salad
Cal
~600
Protein
28g
Carbs
64g
Fat
25g
Ballpark Numbers

About 300 calories a slice. The crust is most of the carbs, and the cheese, pepperoni, and garlic butter are most of the fat. Drinks not counted.

Buon Natale
Two pies, one oven, the whole house.
Pepperoni · Mushroom · Garlic · Herbs