Down on the Georgia and South Carolina coast they call this Frogmore stew, after a little town on St. Helena Island. There's no stew to it. It's a pot of seasoned boiling water and five things that go in at different times so they all finish together.
Use ⅓ cup Old Bay in the water instead of the bag and concentrate. It's milder and more celery-forward, which is the more traditional Lowcountry flavor.
Minutes counted from when the seasoned water hits a rolling boil. The potatoes take the longest, so they go first. The shrimp take the least, so they go last.
Nothing in a boil gets seasoned any other way. Whatever the water tastes like is what everything will taste like, so build it first and give it time.
Small whole potatoes soak up the seasoning while they cook, which is why the potatoes from a boil taste so good.
Anything over about 2 inches, cut in half so it cooks in the same time as the rest.
Frozen corn drops the water temperature a lot. The timer starts once it's boiling again, or everything ends up behind.
Store crab legs are already cooked, so they only need to heat through. Shrimp take two or three minutes and go rubbery if you walk away.
This is the step that separates a good boil from a great one. The ice stops the shrimp from overcooking, and as everything cools a little it pulls the spicy water inside.
The traditional way to serve it is straight onto a table covered in newspaper. No plates, lots of paper towels, a bowl in the middle for shells.
Peel the leftover shrimp, pick the crab, and chop the sausage and potatoes. Tomorrow it's a hash on the griddle with a fried egg on top.
All Georgia and South Carolina, the home of the boil. Otis while the water heats, the fast songs for the fast part, and Hootie when it hits the table.
America's oldest brewery and a staple at boils all over the Southeast. Amber, crisp, and easy. Ice cold in a bucket next to the table.
Salty, citrusy Spanish white made for shellfish. It cuts right through the butter. Spain section, or grab a Vinho Verde from Portugal.
Half sweet tea, half lemonade, with a shot in it. As Southern as the boil.
Shrimp and crab are nearly pure protein. The sausage and the butter are where the fat lives, so those are the two to go easy on. Cocktail sauce adds about 30 calories a serving. Drinks not counted.